Taxpayer Bill of Rights  

II. Explanation of the Bill

Title I. Executive Branch Governance & Management of the IRS
C. Structure & Funding of the Employee Plans &
Exempt Organizations Division ("EP/EO")

(Sec. 1102 of the Bill & Sec. 7803 of the Code)

Present Law

Prior to 1974, no one specific office in the IRS had primary responsibility for employee plans and tax-exempt organizations. As part of the reforms contained in the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 ("ERISA"), Congress statutorily created the Office of Employee Plans and Exempt Organizations ("EP/EO") under the direction of an Assistant Commissioner. EP/EO was created to oversee deferred compensation plans governed by sections 401-414 of the Code and organizations exempt from tax under Code section 501(a).

In general, EP/EO was established in response to concern about the level of IRS resources devoted to oversight of employee plans and exempt organizations. The legislative history of Code section 7802(b) states that, with respect to administration of laws relating to employee plans and exempt organizations, "the natural tendency is for the Service to emphasize those areas that produce revenue rather than those areas primarily concerned with maintaining the integrity and carrying out the purposes of exemption provisions."

To provide funding for the new EP/EO office, ERISA authorized the appropriation of an amount equal to the sum of the section 4940 excise tax on investment income of private foundations (assuming a rate of 2 percent) as would have been collected during the second preceding year plus the greater of the same amount or $30 million. However, amounts raised by the section 4940 excise tax have never been dedicated to the administration of EP/EO, but are transferred instead to general revenues. Thus, the level of EP/EO funding, like that of the rest of the IRS, is dependent on annual Congressional appropriations to the Treasury Department.

Reasons for Change

To facilitate the reorganization of the IRS along functional lines, the Committee believes that the statutory provision requiring the establishment of the Office of Employee Plans and Exempt Organizations under the direction of an Assistant Commissioner should be eliminated. In addition, because the funding formula for EP/EO set forth in section 7802(b)(2) would, if utilized, result in an unstable level of funding that may bear little or no relation to the amount of financial resources actually required by the EP/EO division, the Committee believes that it is appropriate to repeal the funding mechanism.

Explanation of Provision

The bill eliminates the statutory requirement contained in section 7802(b) that there be an "Office of Employee Plans and Exempt Organizations" under the supervision and direction of an Assistant Commissioner. The Committee intends that a comparable structure be created administratively to ensure that adequate resources within the IRS are devoted to oversight of the tax-exempt sector.

In addition, because the funding formula for EP/EO set forth in section 7802(b)(2) would, if utilized, result in an unstable level of funding that may bear little or no relation to the amount of financial resources actually required by the EP/EO division, the bill repeals the funding mechanism. Thus, the appropriate level of funding for EP/EO is, consistent with current practice, subject to annual Congressional appropriations, as are other functions within the IRS. In this regard, however, the Committee believes that, given the magnitude of the sectors EP/EO is charged with regulating, as well as the unique nature of its mandate, an adequately funded EP/EO is extremely important to the efficient and fair administration of the Federal tax system. Accordingly, financial resources for EP/EO should not be constrained on the basis that EP/EO is a "non-core" IRS function; rather, EP/EO, like all functions of the IRS, should be funded so as to promote the efficient and fair administration of the Federal tax system.

For example, it is important to allocate sufficient funds for EP/EO staffing adequately to monitor and assist businesses in establishing and maintaining retirement plans. Recently, in Revenue Procedure 98-22, the IRS announced the expansion of the self-correction programs it offers employers to encourage companies to identify and correct errors without incurring significant penalties. These changes are welcomed, and it is not intended that the elimination of the statutory requirement contained in section 7802(b)(1) or the self-funding mechanism described in section 7802(b)(2) impede the implementation of these and EP/EO's other programs and activities. Rather, it is intended that there be adequate funding for EP/EO, including these self-correction programs that will encourage the establishment and continuation of retirement plans to increase coverage of American workers while protecting the rights of employees to benefits under these plans and maintaining the integrity and purposes of the exemption provisions.

Effective Date

The provision is effective on the date of enactment.

Previous| First | Next

1998 Hearings Main | Taxpayer Bill of Rights Main | Home

  to download the Adobe Acrobat PDF Reader